A new product earns a retail listing when the buyer can see the category earning more with it on the shelf than without it. The case needs evidence of shopper demand, a clear place in the range and an honest estimate of what it replaces. It also needs a margin and gross margin return on inventory investment (GMROI) case, timed to the range review.
New product launch strategy starts with what the retail buyer asks
Retailers list a new product when it answers four questions. Will shoppers buy it? Where should it sit? What will it replace? Is it worth it for the retailer? Research with buyers, distributors and shoppers before launch shapes pack, price and placement while they can still change.
| Retailer question | Evidence that answers it | Who to ask before launch |
|---|---|---|
| Will shoppers buy it? | Concept testing, purchase and repeat intent, retailer read on unmet requests | Target shoppers, store managers, kirana owners |
| Where should it sit? | Decision tree research, fixture navigation, buyer view of category role | Category managers, quick-commerce category teams, shoppers |
| What will it replace? | Source of volume analysis, substitution research, assortment gaps | Buyers, former buyers, distributors |
| Is it worth it for the retailer? | Category growth case, margin model, promotional plan, sell-through forecast | Buyers, former category managers, finance teams |
Source: Nextyn analysis.
How do you get your product into retail stores?
You get a product into retail stores by answering those four questions through the right listing route for each channel. Range reviews, open calls, chain negotiations, platform buying and distributors each work differently. Plan on six to nine months from the first category read to launch, timed to the retailer's next reset.
Range reviews are the main route in grocery. Some retailers also run open calls. Walmart's Open Call drew hundreds of pitches from 48 states in 2024.[15] Pitches are submitted through RangeMe, and selected suppliers get a 30-minute meeting with a merchant.[16] At the October 2025 event about 100 entrepreneurs received "golden tickets" from Walmart.[17]
Shelf space is finite. The average US supermarket carried about 33,248 items in 2025, according to FMI.[5] In 2026 Blinkit offered close to 80,000 SKUs in Delhi NCR, about 50,000 in the next seven cities and about 20,000 beyond.[6]
Why do new products fail in retail?
New products most often fail for reasons that can be tested before launch: a weak benefit, an unclear claim, the wrong price, poor placement or a weak source of volume. The widely repeated "80 to 95%" failure rate is hard to trace. Castellion and Markham's 2013 review put the failure rate closer to 40%.[7]
A 2008 estimate puts US grocery launch failure at 70 to 80%.[8] In 2018 Nielsen BASES data, launches that tested weakly but went to market anyway missed about 80% of the time.[1]
NielsenIQ (NIQ) found in 2023 that 52% of new items with national distribution grew sales in their second year, against 33% of all new items.[9] Circana's 2025 New Product Pacesetters, the top 200 US launches, generated $6.2 billion in first-year sales. They accounted for 21% of total store dollar growth.[10]
Coca-Cola Life's UK sales fell 58% in the year to April 2017, and it was withdrawn that year. Coca-Cola Zero Sugar took the space and reached £115 million in sales within ten months.[11]
How retailers decide which products to stock: the retail buyer's calendar in each channel
Retailers decide which products to stock through a scheduled process. In US and UK grocery it is the range review, run category by category. In India it differs by channel: chain negotiation in modern trade, first-party buying in quick commerce and distributor push in general trade.
What is a range review (line review)?
A range review, also called a line review, is the periodic reset in which a retailer decides which SKUs stay, leave or join a category. It sets the range, the planogram and the space for the next period. Plan buyer interviews five to eight months before launch, and the commercial check three to four months before.
L.E.K. found big-box home-improvement line reviews are "often annual", with many running every two to three years.[12] In 2015 Tesco's wine range went from more than 950 lines to 650.[13] It can also be reversed. Walmart's Project Impact cut assortment between 2009 and 2011, then restored many of the items it had removed.[14]
What are slotting fees?
Slotting fees, also called slotting allowances, are payments a supplier makes to a retailer to secure shelf space for a new product, mainly in US grocery. The FTC's 2003 study found average payments of $2,313 to $21,768 per item, per retailer, per metro area. Surveyed suppliers estimated a national launch could cost $1.5 to $2 million in slotting.[2]
In the UK, the Groceries Supply Code of Practice (GSCOP) bars the largest grocers from requiring listing payments. The exceptions are promotions, and lines not stocked in 25% or more of their stores in the preceding 365 days. There the payment must reasonably reflect listing risk.[18]
| Compared on | US slotting fees | India listing fees |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Payment for shelf space for a new item | Fee to list a SKU in a chain or on a platform, often bundled with margin and ad commitments |
| Rules | Lawful; studied by the FTC in 2003 | Commercial negotiation; no sector code |
Sources: FTC (2003); seller-reported terms (2025 and 2026).[2][21]
How to get a product listed in DMart and other modern-trade chains
A product gets listed in DMart or another Indian modern-trade chain through terms negotiated chain by chain. There is no sector code for listing. Each chain sets its own margin, listing fees, back-end rebates, promotions and payment cycles. Model all of them before the first meeting.
DMart ended March 2025 with 415 stores across ten states.[19] A DMart listing turns on early velocity and a price that fits its value promise. Reliance Retail ended FY25 with 19,340 stores across about 7,000 towns, and its own brands compete for the same shelves.[20]
How do you get a product listed on Blinkit, and what does it cost?
A product gets listed on Blinkit by persuading the platform's category team, which now buys the stock and chooses SKUs for each dark store. Blinkit moved to an inventory-led, first-party model in 2025.[22] About 80% of its net order value was on that model by the September 2025 quarter. Its CEO expects to reach 3,000 dark stores by March 2027.[3][22]
In 2025 sellers reported fees of about ₹25,000 per SKU per state on Blinkit. On Swiggy Instamart they reported ₹8 to 10 lakh per quarter in listing and ad wallets, and on Zepto onboarding bundles from ₹5 to 6 lakh. StartupTalky put platform commissions at 15 to 25% of selling price in 2026.[21] Quick-commerce research keeps the numbers current.
How does a new product get onto kirana shelves?
A new SKU reaches the kirana shelf when the distributor carries it and the salesperson pushes it on the beat. It stays when shoppers ask for it and the distributor and retailer margin and credit make it worth holding. It replaces whatever moves slowest.
Kantar found in 2026 that retailer advocacy sways about 10 to 15% of purchases in established categories. In new or unfamiliar categories it sways 30 to 40%.[23]
Kirana stores held about 91% of India's grocery market in 2025.[4] Traditional trade held about 82% of fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) value in the twelve months to June 2026.[24] The two figures measure different things, grocery spend and FMCG value.
| Channel | Who decides | What it costs to enter |
|---|---|---|
| US grocery and mass | Category buyer, often with a category captain's input | Slotting fees, promotional funding, margin |
| UK grocery | Category buyer and range team | Margin and promotional support; listing payments bounded by GSCOP |
| India modern trade | Chain category team (DMart, Reliance Retail, More, Spencer's) | Listing fees, margin, back-end rebates, promotions |
| India quick commerce | Platform category team buying first party | Seller-reported listing fees, commissions, ad spend |
| India general trade | Distributor, salesperson and kirana owner | Retailer and distributor margin, schemes, credit |
Source: Nextyn analysis. Terms vary by retailer and category.
What is category management, and how does it shape a retail listing?
Category management runs each category as a business unit, in eight steps from category definition to category review. A new product earns a listing when it helps the category meet its role and scorecard. ECR and The Partnering Group formalised the process in the 1990s, and it is still the reference.[25]
What are the 8 steps of category management?
Category management has eight steps, and a pitch that follows them speaks the buyer's language:
- Define the category.
- Assign its role.
- Assess its performance.
- Set a scorecard.
- Choose strategies.
- Choose tactics.
- Implement the plan.
- Review the results.
What is a planogram, and what is assortment planning?
A planogram is the diagram that sets where each product sits and how many facings it gets. Assortment planning chooses which products a store or channel carries to match its shoppers and space. Both belong to step six, category tactics, where a new product meets the shelf.
What is SKU rationalization?
SKU rationalization removes slow-selling SKUs to free space, simplify operations and lift the rest of the range. L.E.K.'s 2024 packaging study estimated that SKU reduction had added 65 to 90 basis points to brand owners' gross margins compared with 2019.[26]
A rationalization frees space a strong entrant can claim. It also raises the bar, because the retailer has shown it will remove products that do not earn their place.
What retail buyers look for: the seven parts of a retail listing pitch
Retail buyers look for evidence that a new product grows the category, not only that it sells. A strong listing pitch has seven parts, from the category growth case to a sell-through plan.
| Part | Evidence to include |
|---|---|
| 1. Category growth case | Market data by segment and price tier, retailer interviews on unmet requests |
| 2. Incrementality and source of volume | Switching research, concept test source of volume, cannibalization estimate |
| 3. Shopper evidence | Concept testing, purchase and repeat intent, shopper interviews, early sales data |
| 4. Margin and GMROI model | Margin at shelf price, rate of sale, stock cover, GMROI, fees |
| 5. Promotional plan | Launch calendar, media, sampling, in-store and retail media plans, promotional funding |
| 6. Supply reliability | Capacity, lead times, service-level targets, distributor coverage |
| 7. Sell-through plan | Week-by-week targets, reporting cadence, actions if rate of sale is below plan |
Source: Nextyn analysis.[12][25]
Incrementality is the part buyers read most closely. If a new item sells 2,500 units and existing items lose 1,000, the cannibalization rate is 40%. The retailer's real gain is 1,500 units. NIQ noted in 2022 that standard sales metrics alone do not show this.[27] Condense the pitch into a one-page sell sheet, and show the promotional plan and supply plan together.
What is GMROI?
GMROI, gross margin return on inventory investment, is annual gross margin divided by the average cost of inventory held. It shows whether a product earns its space. A faster-selling product with a slightly lower margin can beat a slow, high-margin one on GMROI.
How do you plan market research for a new product launch?
Market research for a new product launch works best in a set order, before pack, price and placement lock. Start with category data, then buyers, former buyers and quick-commerce category teams. Then speak with distributors, store managers and kirana owners. Then test the concept with shoppers, and close with a commercial check.
| Stage and timing | Who | Decision it informs |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Category read: 6 to 9 months before launch | Desk research: retail measurement, platform data, filings | Which segment and price tier to target |
| 2. Buyer and operator interviews: 5 to 8 months before | Modern-trade buyers, category managers, quick-commerce category teams, former buyers | Channel priority, listing case, launch timing |
| 3. Trade interviews: 5 to 7 months before | Distributors, salespeople, store managers, kirana owners | Trade terms, pack size for general trade |
| 4. Shopper concept testing: 4 to 6 months before | Target shoppers, by mission and channel | Pack, claim, price |
| 5. Commercial check: 3 to 4 months before | Buyers, former category managers, internal finance | Pitch, launch budget, go or adjust |
| 6. Early read: weeks 1 to 12 after launch | Store managers, dark-store data, distributors, shoppers | Corrections before the first review |
Source: Nextyn analysis.
Our paper on category intelligence from retailer interviews covers how to run the buyer conversations.
Concept testing measures how target shoppers respond to a product idea before it is fixed. It checks whether the need is real, whether the claim is clear and credible, and whether the price feels right.
Sell in vs sell through: managing channel inventory after a retail listing
A listing secures sell in. The reorder, the facings and the next range review depend on sell through, so set sell-through targets by store or dark store from the first week.
What is the difference between sell in and sell through?
Sell in is the stock a brand ships into the channel. Sell through is what shoppers buy. The gap between them is channel inventory, sitting in distributor warehouses, back rooms, dark stores and kirana shelves. The question is whether sell through catches up.
Strong sell in with weak sell through fills the pipeline, and the correction arrives later. At Honasa Consumer, an inventory correction took about ₹63 crore off reported sales in the second quarter of FY25.[28] From retail audit to shopper insight covers how to diagnose a slow store.
In the first 90 days, track rate of sale, days of cover, repeat rate and distribution achieved, which on-shelf availability checks confirm.
| Sell in | Sell through on or above plan | Sell through below plan |
|---|---|---|
| Sell in on or above plan | Healthy launch. Protect availability and widen distribution. | Pipeline building. Find the slow stores, ask why, and slow shipments before stock ages. |
| Sell in below plan | Demand is ahead of supply or distribution. Fix coverage and supply first. | Go back to buyers and shoppers on demand, placement and the retailer case before investing further. |
Source: Nextyn analysis.
How does cannibalization change a new product's GMROI? A worked example
In this illustrative scenario, cannibalization and the delisted SKU mean the brand's ₹18.7 lakh becomes ₹10.4 lakh of net new category sales. GMROI falls from about 7.3 to 4.4. It is not a client case: a hypothetical 40 g millet snack at ₹30 enters a 100-store chain. A slow 30 g SKU is delisted to free two facings.
| Line | Assumption | Sales (₹) | Gross margin (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|
| New SKU sales | 12 units at ₹30, retailer margin 22% | 360 | 79 |
| Less: cannibalization | 40% of units (4.8) would have bought another bay SKU at an average ₹25, margin 20% | (120) | (24) |
| Less: delisted SKU | Sold 5 units at ₹20, margin 20%; 60% of its buyers switch to other bay SKUs, 40% of its sales lost | (40) | (8) |
| Net new category result | 200 | 47 |
Across 100 stores and 52 weeks, the brand counts about ₹18.7 lakh (₹360 × 100 × 52). The category gains about ₹10.4 lakh (₹200 × 100 × 52). Some of the delisted SKU's buyers may switch to the new snack itself, so the loss line is a cautious assumption.
Suppose each store holds about two weeks of stock, 24 units, or about ₹562 at cost. On its own margin, the new SKU earns about ₹4,118 a year per store (₹79.20 × 52), a GMROI of about 7.3. On net new category margin it earns about ₹2,454 (₹47.20 × 52), a GMROI of about 4.4. Buyers who count cannibalization use the second figure.
The product earns its space wherever the bay's average GMROI is below about 4.4. At 5 or 6 it passes on its own margin but not on net new margin.
How this paper was built
This paper draws on public sources published between 2003 and November 2026. Quick-commerce listing fees are seller reported and indicative. Statistics that could not be traced to a primary source, such as the claim that 95% of new products fail, were not used as evidence.
Frequently asked questions about retail listings and new product launches
Sources: the 28 public sources behind the full report
- 01
Nielsen BASES (2018). Setting the record straight on innovation failure.
https://www.promotionmagazine.it/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/2018_Nielsen_Innovation_Failure.pdf - 02
US Federal Trade Commission (2003). Slotting Allowances in the Retail Grocery Industry.
https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/reports/use-slotting-allowances-retail-grocery-industry/slottingallowancerpt031114.pdf - 03
The Week, PTI (2025). Eternal posts Rs 65 cr consolidated net profit in Q2; Blinkit drives growth.
https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/business/2025/10/16/dcm78-biz-results-ld-eternal.html - 04
Redseer (2026). Why India's mass grocery still leans on kirana stores. Redseer, Rethinking the FMCG market in India's hybrid retail economy.
https://redseer.com/reports/why-indias-mass-grocery-still-leans-on-kirana-stores/
https://redseer.com/digests/rethinking-fmcg-market-in-indias-hybrid-retail-economy/ - 05
FMI (2025). Food industry facts, citing The Food Retailing Industry Speaks.
https://fmi.org/our-research/food-industry-facts - 06
Business Today (2026). Blinkit is coming for Amazon's shelf. Open Magazine (2026). Blinkit wants your whole shopping list.
https://www.businesstoday.in/markets/story/blinkit-is-coming-for-amazons-shelf-544999-2026-07-24
https://openthemagazine.com/business/blinkit-wants-your-whole-shopping-list-can-its-economics-keep-up - 07
Castellion, G. and Markham, S. (2013). New Product Failure Rates: Influence of Argumentum ad Populum and Self Interest. Journal of Product Innovation Management.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jpim.12050 - 08
Oregon State University PACE, citing Inez Blackburn, University of Toronto (2008 presentation, cited by Oregon State PACE). Why new food products fail.
https://blog.pace.oregonstate.edu/why-new-food-products-fail - 09
NielsenIQ (2023). Innovation vitality: the payoff is worth the pursuit.
https://nielseniq.com/global/en/insights/commentary/2023/innovation-vitality-the-payoff-is-worth-the-pursuit - 10
Circana (2026). 2025 New Product Pacesetters.
https://www.circana.com/post/circana-unveils-2025-new-product-pacesetters-as-top-innovations-drive-6-2-billion-in-year-one-sales - 11
BeverageDaily (2017). Coca-Cola Life axed in the UK.
https://www.beveragedaily.com/Article/2017/04/07/Coca-Cola-Life-axed-in-the-UK - 12
L.E.K. Consulting (2021). Ensuring success in home improvement big box product line reviews.
https://www.lek.com/insights/building-construction/ensuring-success-home-improvement-big-box-product-line-reviews - 13
Harpers Wine and Spirit (2015). Tesco drops 300 wines from range; Wine agency suppliers to be hardest hit in Tesco range cull. The Grocer (2015). Tesco calls in BCG to oversee range review. The Drinks Business (2015).
https://www.harpers.co.uk/news/fullstory.php/aid/18320/Tesco_drops_300_wines_from_range_and_eliminates_half_price_deals.html
https://www.harpers.co.uk/news/fullstory.php/aid/16904/Wine_agency_suppliers_to_be_hardest_hit_in_Tesco_range_cull.html
https://www.thegrocer.co.uk/supermarkets/tesco-calls-in-management-consultants-bcg-to-oversee-drastic-range-review/512897.article
https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2015/10/tesco-adopts-aldi-and-lidls-fixed-price-model/ - 14
RetailWire (2011). Walmart reverses course on SKU rationalization.
https://retailwire.com/discussion/walmart-reverses-course-on-sku-rationalization/ - 15
Walmart (2025). Building on a legacy: Walmart's Open Call 2025 applications now live.
https://corporate.walmart.com/news/2025/06/24/building-on-a-legacy-walmarts-open-call-2025-applications-now-live - 16
Walmart (2026). Open Call FAQs.
https://corporate.walmart.com/suppliers/investing-in-american-jobs/events/annual-open-call/open-call-faqs - 17
Talk Business and Politics (2026). Walmart begins again the Open Call process.
https://talkbusiness.net/2026/03/walmart-begins-again-the-open-call-process/ - 18
GOV.UK, Competition Commission (2009). Groceries Supply Code of Practice, paragraphs 9, 12 and 16.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/groceries-supply-code-of-practice/groceries-supply-code-of-practice - 19
Avenue Supermarts (2025). Annual Report 2024 to 25. Storyboard18 (2025). DMart Q4 FY25 results.
https://files.tijorifinance.com/insight/india/6857/Annual%20Report/AR-25.pdf
https://www.storyboard18.com/amp/brand-marketing/dmart-q4-fy25-revenue-rises-16-8-to-rs-14872-crore-net-profit-slips-2-2-to-rs-551-crore-64513.htm - 20
Storyboard18 (2025). Reliance Retail FY25 results; Campa Cola gains double digit market share.
https://storyboard18.com/brand-marketing/reliance-retail-revenue-rises-8-in-fy25-campa-cola-gains-double-digit-market-share-79878.htm - 21
Storyboard18 (2025). Quick commerce's ad fee toll. Seller reported figures. StartupTalky (2026), quick commerce costs for D2C brands.
https://www.storyboard18.com/brand-marketing/quick-commerces-ad-fee-toll-are-platforms-squeezing-out-small-d2c-brands-73952.htm
https://startuptalky.com/quick-commerce-real-cost-d2c-brands/ - 22
YourStory (2025). Blinkit eyes margin shifts with inventory model.
https://yourstory.com/2025/07/blinkit-eyes-margin-shifts-inventory-model-sight-3000-dark-stores - 23
Kantar (2026). The kirana shopkeeper influence myth. Kantar Shopper Intelligence.
https://www.kantar.com/inspiration/brands/kirana-shopkeeper-influence-myth - 24
NielsenIQ (2026). India FMCG Quarterly Snapshot, Q2 2026.
https://nielseniq.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2026/08/NIQ-India-FMCG-Quarterly-Snapshot_Q226-AMJ26.pdf - 25
GS1 Germany and ECR (accessed 2026). Category management. FMI (1999). Category management road map.
https://www.gs1-germany.de/en/themen/category-management/
https://www.fmi.org/newsroom/news-archive/view/1999/02/08/new-report-provides-detailed-road-map-to-help-supermarket-industry-realize-full-potential-of-category-management - 26
L.E.K. Consulting (2024). Annual Packaging Study: What happened to SKU proliferation?
https://www.lek.com/insights/paper-packaging/annual-packaging-study-what-happened-sku-proliferation - 27
NielsenIQ (2022). The value of incrementality.
https://nielseniq.com/global/en/insights/education/2022/the-value-of-incrementality-seeing-the-full-assortment-picture/ - 28
YourStory (2024). Distribution woes and inventory correction at Honasa. Business Standard (2024).
https://yourstory.com/2024/11/distribution-woes-inventory-correction-mamaearth-honasa-consumer
https://www.business-standard.com/amp/markets/news/honasa-consumer-stock-hits-10-lower-limit-down-36-in-3-days-post-q2-show-124112100639_1.html
The worked example in this paper is illustrative and uses invented numbers. The brand, the product, the retailer and every number in it do not describe any real company or Nextyn client.
Company figures from filings and press reports have not been independently audited. Brand examples are drawn from public information and are not Nextyn clients unless stated.
Hero photograph: ha ha / Pexels.